Autumn 2010 / Leading Edge
Can Our Forests Stand the Heat?

Scientists discover unusual die-off in sugar-maple leaves due to high spring temperatures


Photo: Moodboard/Corbis

You might expect warm weather to be good for trees. But new research by professors and students in the Faculty of Forestry suggests that a balmy spring can be bad for temperate forests. The group, studying a patch of forest in the Haliburton Highlands, discovered that many sugar-maple leaves that developed during three record-hot days in May died without expanding to their full size; other leaves are stunted.

“In early June, when the canopy should be its greenest, the canopy was tinged brown,” says Sean Thomas, the Canada Research Chair in Forests and Environmental Change and a professor of forestry. “In my 10 years of working in this region I’ve never seen anything like this. The foresters I work with who have been there many decades have never seen anything like this.”

Thomas and his colleagues noticed the dying leaves in a 13.5-hectare research plot near Algonquin Provincial Park. Work began on this particular patch of forest – the first of such research “mega-plots” in North America – in 2007 in an effort to understand temperate forests through intensive study. It’s a method that was pioneered 30 years ago in Panama and Malaysia to study tropical forests, and to yield insight into a little-studied ecosystem.

But Thomas says that we also have a lot to learn about temperate and boreal forests. Although scientists have studied and managed these forests for decades, their focus has often been on growing healthy trees quickly for logging. “Most of the history of traditional forestry research has been narrowly applied,” he says.

Researchers at the Haliburton mega-plot are trying to learn everything they can about the basic biology of the forest. The first step was to record, measure and map every woody-stemmed plant with a diameter of one centimetre or more – about 47,000 plants in all. This work was completed last summer, and a team of graduate students are now analyzing the data. The census will allow them to track the growth and mortality of every tree in the forest over years.

Scientists working on the plot use a network of 180 temperature sensors and a nearby meteorological instrument tower. The 30-metre-high tower, run in collaboration with Jennifer Murphy, a professor of chemistry, and Nate Basiliko, a professor of geography, uses special equipment to measure the exchange of carbon dioxide, methane and other gases between the forest and the atmosphere.

Thomas says the death of new leaves is an effect few would have predicted for warmer springs; the researchers have ruled out other causes, such as disease, pests and rainfall. The finding is a good example of the sort of unexpected consequences of global warming that the forest plot and instrumentation will help researchers understand. For instance, if warmer temperatures are going to kill leaves more often in the future, and if the death of those leaves slows forest growth or reduces the intake of carbon dioxide, then global warming might be quicker and more severe than currently predicted.


Reader Comments

# 1
Posted by Joe Yaraskavitch http://BScF1989 on September 28th, 2010 @ 10:37 am

Leaves were “killed” by a heavy frost, damage was widespread across central Ontario. Very warm temperatures caused leaves to flush out early, then cold temperatures (frost) killed the leaves.

# 2
Posted by Dale Leadbeater http://BSc974 on October 5th, 2010 @ 12:42 pm

Joe has it right. You must be inundated with similar comments. The researchers seem to have completely missed the fact that after three weeks of record heat, Haliburton was treated to killing frosts which kicked the stuffing out of the trees. The local maple syrup producers are concerned that it will affect the 2011 syrup production and they are likely right. I recall driving up a couple of weeks after the frost and there were dead leaves littering the roads. It was reminiscent of the Forest Tent Caterpillar infestation some years ago, except that the fragments were much larger and there were more of them. The trees never recovered. I suspect this may be a case of the students starting their research after classes were out, and finishing when they had to be back in September, missing critical events in the growing season.

Add a Comment

required, use real name
required, Not for Publication
optional, eg: BSc 2008

Next story in this issue: »
Previous story in this issue: «